Your share in the conversation

This week we’ve been celebrating From Pemberley to Milton’s 5th anniversary with daily posts and giveaways, and on Monday, I shared with you some of my stats asking you to share your preferences with as well, so today we are revealing what the followers of From Pemberley to Milton are interested in reading 🙂

Only 13% of readers read exclusively Jane Austen Fan Fiction novels, but even though the other 87% read something else in between, I believe the majority of books people who visit this website read are indeed JAFF. If someone would ask me that question, I would also say I don’t read exclusively JAFF, but the non-austenesque books I read per year is on average around 4 or 5.

This year I’ve read 43 books so I’m expecting to reach 60 at the end of the year, but I had the idea that most of my visitors read even more than I do, so I asked you how many books you read per year. It turns out I was right! Even though 42% “only” read between 0 and 25 books per year, if we sum the percentage of people who read above 50 books per year we get the exact same percentage.


Now, one may think that people who read over 100 books per year may be reading novellas with a reduced number of pages, but the truth is no one expressed their preference to be books below 100 pages.

In fact, the majority of readers share my preference and is more fond of books between 200 and 300 pages. 25% of readers actually prefers books with more than 300 pages, so it appears that readers do prefer longer books to shorter ones. I for one have been growing a special relationship with smaller books:)


But which books are readers really buying? I was almost certain that, just like me, readers would prefer variations over other types of novels, but what do they like to read apart from that? If we were to remove variations of the equation, what would readers like to read most? To try to understand that I asked readers to tell me what is their favourite genre, but also their second favourite. As expected, 66% of readers prefer variations above all others, but there is also a big percentage of people who prefer Austen Inspired novels to all other genres, and this was quite a surprise. 11% is not a high value, but I certainly wasn’t expecting it to be the second type of novel readers prefer, it even comes before sequels which are the favourite genre for 8% of readers.

If we move to people’s second favourite genre we can see that tastes are a bit more diverse and this will provide us the answer to my previous question, if we remove variations out of the equation, what do people like to read? Well, those who did not choose it as a first option chose it now as a second one, so the conclusion is indeed what we were expecting, variations are definitely THE genre people like to read! But on this graphic we can also see that Different Eras, including modernizations are also growing among the community. 25% of readers states that  these are their second favourite genre, and 15% indicates that sequels and Different POV’s are their favourites.

6% of readers states that their favourite genre is Secondary Characters, and 10% states this is their second favourite type of novels, but who are these secondary characters that readers like to know more about? Well, it’s no shocker but I wasn’t expecting such a high percentage! Colonel Fitzwilliam is definitely in people’s hearts! However, there aren’t many stories where he is the main character, are they? I can only think of Colonel Fitzwilliam’s Challenge by Jennifer Joy and When Mary Met the Colonel by Victoria Kincaid. Do you know of any other? Or maybe he is a favourite within a Darcy/Elizabeth story?

Mary Bennet comes second and she is also a favourite of mine! Thankfully there are many books that are centered in Mary 🙂

There was also a big percentage of people answering None of the Above which was completely unexpected to me because most of Pride and Prejudice characters are present here, so maybey people’s favourites are from other Austen novels. I’ll make sure to include that on a future survey 🙂


What about the storyline? What do people like and dislike? I confess the options could have been better but when I added the option Other with the possibility to write something, I was hoping you would tell me your favourite and least favourite plotlines and that I would be able to agregate them per category, and add them to these graphics, but unfortunely WordPress isn’t allowing me to see what you wrote, so we’re stuck with the options I created. I think I’ll need to think this trough a little better next time I do a survey.

From the options I created, clearly the forced marriage scenario and Darcy and Elizabeth stranded somewhere take the lead on people’s preferences, followed by Elizabeth being above Darcy in society, which is funny because that is one of my least favourite plots. The Love Triangle is also the favourite of 8% of people, and with that one I can relate to, I love to have some rivals for their affections in the story 🙂

What about the least favourite plots? On this one readers preferences also match my own, 23 % of readers dislike having different pairings, and I’m assuming that’s when it comes to Darcy and Elizabeth, so I obviously agree with that, I mean, Darcy is supposed to end up with Elizabeth and I can’t even think of a book that has a different outcome. If there are books with this plot out there, I’ve never read them. 21% of readers states that Darcy and/or Elizabeth  marrying someone else first is the plot they like the least, followed by them having a child with someone else first, which I believe is my least favourite.

Sci-Fi and paranormal are also amongst readers least favourite plots and that is a pity for me because I love these two genres and I think that bringing them into JAFF would be an added value. 

Elizabeth not being a Bennet is no big deal for my readers, and on this one my opinion is a little different, I do like when their circumstances are very close to canon, so when they differ, I tend to dislike the plot.

Was this interesting? Did you like to know what other readers preferences are? Is there anything you would like to know that was not asked? Let me know! I love doing these stats and getting to know readers preferences better, so I would love to repeat this initiative with your input 🙂

I was suppose to change the blog layout today, but to be honest, I chickened out.

I have an appointment this evening and I am too nervous and afraid to do this on a rush before leaving home, so I am going to do it tomorrow because it is a non-working day and I’ll have more time to fix some issue that may occur. Plus, my husband told me he wanted to be out of the house when I decided to renovate the blog. In case something goes wrong, he wants to be as far away from me and my screams as possible 🙂 So fingers crossed for tomorrow!

I know I’m probably making a huge fuss out of this, but I am so bad with technology that even something as simple as this is a big thing for me. Anyway, see you all tomorrow and hope to hear from all of you on Sunday when I announce the winners of this week’s giveaway 🙂


Filed under JAFF

18 responses to “Your share in the conversation

  1. Glynis

    I really enjoyed this! I do like opinion polls. Re the other secondary character I think mine would be The Gardiners and they weren’t there!
    I’m not surprised you chickened out on changing your blog without having the time to concentrate fully. I wouldn’t even know where to start in the first place. So, good luck! I hope all goes well.


  2. Sophia Rose

    I have been curious about the survey all week. I’m glad to see what the group replied compared to my replies. Bummer about the ‘Other’ responses not showing up for you. It was a lot of fun filling it out and seeing the results. Thanks, Rita!

    And, good luck with your blog renovations.


  3. I admit that out of the nearly 500 stories I have this year only 130 are JAFF related, and I know of about dozen books which the main story is the Colonel and Mary Bennet – I just wish there were more.


  4. Very informative. Sort of explained why the Mary story I just wrote wasn’t a big favorite. Lol Thank you!


  5. J. W. Garrett

    This was so much fun and such a surprise to see the preferences of your blog followers. I love bar-graphs. Thanks for doing this and I agree that tomorrow would be better for the cut-over with the new design on the website. You need a good night’s sleep. You would have gone to your appointment and worried yourself sick until you got home to see if it and your house was still standing. Bless your heart. Blessings on the new website face-lift, stay safe, and healthy.


  6. Rita, thank you for the thoughtful poll questions. It’s always good to discover what fans of our genre enjoy.

    Now I’m off to come up with a forced marriage scenario … 😀


  7. Robin G.

    Very interesting, thank you, Rita! It would be fascinating to revisit this again at some point and see how things change. A really good book by an author could change people’s views and perceptions of what they are willing to read. As to the least favorite plots, I interpreted “different pairings” to mean that while Darcy and Elizabeth are a given, the different pairings were for Jane, Bingley, Charlotte, Anne, etc. Otherwise, I would have changed my answer to that as my least favorite. LOL!


  8. I think it’s wonderful you did the survey and enjoyed the results.



  9. Lucy Marin

    This is great. I love some good statistics, and it was really interesting to see the responses. 🙂 Congrats on the anniversary!


  10. alexandrariverstories

    Good luck with the blog renovation!
    (If you are bad with technology…)


  11. Such interesting results. Thanks for posting, particularly as this must have been quite a bit of work to pull all the information together. Also, good luck with the blog redesign. I’ve been meaning to redesign mine for about 2 years, including switching to WordPress, but I never seem to have enough time and I am frightened of breaking it! So I will really be looking forward to seeing yours and wish you all the best with it. Big hugs!


  12. maryvad

    Hi Rita,
    No surprises,for the most part,from the poll.

    May I suggest,if you’re a morning person,to get up early tomorrow and
    launch into the creation of your new blog. Your brain will be fresh and you may very well surprise yourself with how much work you get done,in a short amount of time.
    I did just this during the week when I was doing an online course. I got all the material read,assignments complete and responses penned by yesterday afternoon.

    I wish you the best of luck with it. 🍀No doubt it will be a resounding success.
    Looking forward to the great reveal. Stay safe.


  13. Thank you for such an effort, very interesting results.


  14. Mary has become a particular favorite of mine! But I would also love to see more books about Charlotte Lucas. I feel for her being stuck with that horrid Mr Collins and so want her to find some happiness.


  15. Charlotte

    Lol, no surprise that Lady Catherine isn’t a favorite 😀 Fun to see what everyone picked!!


  16. Such a great post! Loved the graphs and people’s choices! Col Fitzwilliam our favourite by such a margin (hehe, no surprise there 😀 ). The soft spot for forced marriage scenarios. And for D & E stranded somewhere together with no one to interfere ❤ . It was such fun to vote and so interesting to see the results. Thanks, Rita!


  17. Dung

    Love seeing what everyone’s choices and the poll results! Always find it so fascinating! Cheers to more reading and 4-5 star reads!


  18. sheilalmajczan

    Just reading this blog post – interesting results on the graph. Thanks for sharing.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.